"The problem is Becky got on the stand and lied about whether she had given a juror a ride home, and the defense correctly identified that in their closing argument. But one of the other things missing in that closing argument was one of the jurors lied about it too. We don't know which one, but nobody said they got a ride home from Becky Hill, so one of the jurors lied about it as well, and that's huge. That goes to the direct credibility of these jurors," says Murray.